Is mixing of paradigms a problem or a solution?

Home Forums Default Forum Is mixing of paradigms a problem or a solution?

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1764
    Santosh Mishra
    Participant

    Mixed Methods Research involves mixing of paradigms. Though some feel that it is problematic and unacceptable, some others claim that such unions may be helpful in carrying out research in more reliable and valid ways. I request you to share your thoughts regarding the above mentioned viewpoints. Thank you.

    #1771
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    DWhen you say ‘paradigm’, do you mean a research philosophy or a research design? Could you give some paradigms that you think that could be combined in mixed methods?

    #1770
    Santosh Mishra
    Participant

    Sorry Linda! I should have mentioned that by paradigm I meant the underlying philosophies like Positivism, Constructivism, etc. Thanks for drawing my attention.

    Best

    Santosh

    #1769
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Pragmatism or critical realism are often mentioned as paradigms for mixed methods.  The approach in pragmatism is that your research questions should determine the research method you adopt. Sage publish the Journal of Mixed Methods Research and there are some useful articles in there.

    #1768

    Since different philosophies usually make fundamentally incompatible assumptions about the social world, I find it difficult to bridge different paradigms and would say it is a problem, not a solution to anything.

    #1767

    As synthesis or as dialectical issue, mixing is an acceptable, justifiable proposal. Specific paradigms could also be wrong in their application.

    #1766
    Willie 17
    Member

    As Ingo mentioned, mixing two divergent assumptions could be problematic, and overly confusing particularly to novince researchers. I am against blending two opposing assumptions on the philosophical level, but seems doable on the technical level (data collection techniques). 

    #1765
    Catherine Westbrook
    Participant

    Have you read Chapter 10 of Tashakkori and Teddlie Mixed Methods in Social and Behavioral Research by Stephen Gorard? A very forthright opinion on the fakeness of paradigms (his opinion – not mine)..but an interesting viewpoint none the less.

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
  • The forum ‘Default Forum’ is closed to new topics and replies.